Sure, there are rare situations where fighting evil humans is thrust upon us, but such situations are just that, rare. So, feel free to do what you must in that unlikely event, and let’s set the subject aside, as seductively theatric as it may be.
This setting aside is important, because “fighting evil” in any kind of societal application is a demonstrably failed strategy.
Failures Left and Right
Today we’ll pick on the left to begin with, then switch to the right.
The “fighting evil” strategy of the political left is socialism. It has gained a foothold among the young for three primary reasons:
They are too young to remember socialism in practice.
They are so poorly schooled that they don’t see any problem with it.
The people promoting socialism complain very well.
I’m not trying to be trite or insulting with these three points; they’re the actual reasons.
Complaints about the way things are have a great deal of legitimacy, of course. Student loans are one of the more abusive schemes ever thrust upon a generation… deeply manipulative and deeply abusive. (I explain in some depth here.)
On top of that abuse, the truth is that the rich are becoming richer and the poor, poorer((This is not the fault of capitalism (actual capitalism, that is) and it’s not the fault of money per se. It’s the fault of national economic systems that call themselves capitalist and which run the economies of the world.)).
Bear in mind that these problem exist on the heels of a century of “fighting the rich.” Very clearly, the left’s “fighting evil” strategy didn’t work.
And it’s worth adding that while the complaints above are legitimate, invoking socialism to fight them has to be one of the most boneheaded strategies in human history. Not only has it not worked despite a century of massive efforts, but socialism has proven itself to be death incarnate((For what it’s worth, socialism was supposed to be a transition phase from capitalism to communism. A proper communist society would have no state per se. But please bear in mind that avowed communists can argue about these things for days on end.)). The Soviet socialists killed tens of millions. The Chinese socialists killed many tens of millions. Cambodian socialists killed roughly a third of their populace in only a few years.
Socialism is a way for a few to live like kings, while the masses praising them die in huge numbers. Period.
Now, let’s pick on the right.
I got an email recently, in which a friend shared a passage he’d read. It said, roughly, this:
Through the late ’50s and early ’60s the US was essentially a live-and-let-live place, with Christian proclivities. This began to change when the Marxists began infiltrating our universities, reaching critical mass in the ’70s and ’80s. No reformation movement can succeed until we treat cultural Marxism like we treated the war on smallpox.
I responded that while there is some truth in the passage (I’ve addressed it previously), the prescription of treating it as “a war on…” is useless. While most people no longer remember, groups like the John Birch Society have been doing precisely this since the 1950s and even earlier. And despite all their “fighting evil” efforts… and even with its incredible crash and burn of the late 1980s… socialism still seduces.
And so, again, “fighting evil” got us more or less nowhere.
If you want progress in the world – if you want people to live happier, freer, more satisfying lives – there is a very simple and effective answer: Start building it yourself.
Not only does this work, but it’s more or less the only thing that works. A lot of people don’t like the idea, because it requires effort and because they’ve been seduced by the big lie of democratic politics, which is this:
If you can complain well enough, the machinery of the state will create what you want.
And so, people who believe that complaining makes it so (a near-relative of wishing makes it so) are hesitant to build. After all, building is harder than complaining, and they might get into trouble.
And so the politician who best pretends to care gets elected, and there’s no reason for anything to change. The politicians promise and the people believe, as the generations come and go. Ho hum.
So, if you want things to improve, roll up your sleeves and get busy. Cryptocurrencies, biohacking, 3D-printed housing, flying cars (scaled-up drones), automated agriculture, and many other improvements stand waiting for your efforts. In fact, we publish a monthly newsletter that teaches you how to get involved.
So, make a choice… and make it a good one.
* * * * *
The novel that helped put the crypto revolution into high gear.
Comments from readers:
“Of the twenty five or so people I worked with last fall, all of them revered A Lodging of Wayfaring Men as a bible. They referred to the house and their community effort as a Lodge. We all felt it was modeled on the Free Souls.”
“Actually, I am somewhat at a loss as to how I might explain how I feel about this book other than to say what a great mind to write such an awesome story!”
“I’m an Old guy and find that Rosenberg has captured many Real-World truths in this novel. I wish the Millennial Generation would read this novel and consider the concepts and rationale presented here.”
Get it at Amazon or on Kindle.
* * * * *
One thought on “Fighting Evil Is a Failed Strategy”
I authored the post that your friend referenced in their email, regarding the treatment of Cultural Marxism like Smallpox. I cited the university system as the ‘vector’ for this disease, as nearly all of our politicians, economists, journalists, and ALL of our children’s teachers are products of this environment. Thus, it is THE MOST dangerous of all our institutions – it is the disease that keeps on giving, as in………Smallpox. While I am in general agreement with your approach, i.e. building a new society vs fighting the old one, this would seem to be practical only within a VERY short radius of one’s household. Our so-called sovereign states have become complicit with the FEDS in their war against your personal independence, outlawing the sale of raw milk, braiding hair, selling lemonade or cooked goods without a license, et al. As for your children’s education, home-schooling is excellent, but Engineering and Medicine are not likely to become kitchen table disciplines. So, is it your position that we abandon these corrupted institutions, most of which were built over a period of two hundred years, mostly on the backs of the everyday taxpayer, and just c’est la vie? How does one ignore the invading hordes who have declared open war on you, your property, your speech, your thoughts, the minds of your children, your livelihood, your means of self-defense, your value system, and even your very existence?
My final point – you seem repelled by the term ‘war,’ referencing the futile efforts of organizations like the John Birch Society to effect meaningful change. I see the problem differently. I believe the overarching reason for the inability of ‘conservatives’ to hold ground against the socialist-Marxist tide is precisely due to their failure to put their cohorts on a war-time footing, to awaken their fellow patriots to the existential threats facing them, and to treat the threats with the same gravity as would the village inhabitants facing the Mongol hordes. In fact, ‘going to war’ is in our DNA, we’ve been doing it for millenniums. A war mindset is capable of animating even the most sanguine among us to sacrifice their own children to campaigns far less worthy than that we are now facing. The idea of ‘war,’ I believe, is more familiar, more saleable, more tangible, more inspiring, and would resonate more deeply with the people who care about our system of values, than the ethereal concept of ‘just ignore them and build a different, better society.’
We’re on the same team, Paul (I think) and I admire your passion in seeking solutions to seemingly intractable problems. Somewhere under the Aegean Stables, I’m hoping, is a pony.
Comments are closed.