The Maturity Level of Politics


A recent article by Joe Katzman illustrated the maturity level of modern politics, by explaining the true nature of the war raging between Donald Trump and the American media. And what it showed was that winning and losing in politics comes down to the same kind of insults that work on a fifth grade playground.

The article (from a political-right perspective) defines a core principle of politics: That status and identification are fundamental, and that reasoned arguments are to be assiduously avoided. But it goes on to explain the power of the news media:

Why do the media have power? Because they have social status with ordinary people… How many movies seem to exist just to show journalists as heroes? … What’s the attraction of such a low-paying profession? Status given by the profession, and status from rubbing shoulders with high-status people.

This is important. Fast and cheap status has been the road to serfdom since ancient Mesopotamia, and it’s still feeding upon human weaknesses… using the news media as a status provider.

What Donald Trump is doing, the article argues, is attacking the status of the news media. Katzman writes:

Trump also acts in ways that cause journalists to fulfill his pre-suasion labeling. He makes “outrageous” statements, which many people outside the Beltway Bubble agree with. Those statements receive over-the-top media attacks, which make his enemies look ridiculous. Then events swiftly show that Trump had a point. Trump rubs it in, using the media’s own “Fake News” term against them and pouncing on every sloppy and dishonest mistake.

Notice that from the standpoint of a fight on a 5th grade schoolyard, this is the perfect strategy. Notice also that it works brilliantly in politics, which functions, necessarily, at something like a 5th grade level.

And it’s not just Trump. The left used to employ a man named James Carville to make the same kinds of attacks on the right.

We may not like playground bullies at the highest levels of government, but this is what politics produces. Reason loses badly in almost any political fight. Base instincts are what win: Fear, status, tribal identification, and so on.

Last year I wrote this:

…if we’re very, very lucky, the [winner of the] Donny and Hillary circus may break the stasis of our time.

If Katzman is right, the news media may be shoved from their high-and-holy perch, which may help break our era’s frozen status quo. Let’s just hope that our current batch of young people can mature better than their forebears.

* * * * *

A book that generates comments like these, from actual readers, might be worth your time:

  • I just finished reading The Breaking Dawn and found it to be one of the most thought-provoking, amazing books I have ever read… It will be hard to read another book now that I’ve read this book… I want everyone to read it.
  • Such a tour de force, so many ideas. And I am amazed at the courage to write such a book, that challenges so many people’s conceptions.
  • There were so many points where it was hard to read, I was so choked up.
  • Holy moly! I was familiar with most of the themes presented in A Lodging of Wayfaring Men, but I am still trying to wrap my head around the concepts you presented at the end of this one.

Get it at Amazon ($18.95) or on Kindle: ($5.99)


* * * * *

Paul Rosenberg

One thought on “The Maturity Level of Politics”

  1. “If Katzman is right, the news media may be shoved from their high-and-holy perch, which may help break our era’s frozen status quo.”
    The numbers referenced in the article say that they are being shoved; indeed, have mostly been shoved off among Republicans and Independent voters. Not to mention rather a few Bernie supporters, who got their own first-hand look at media corruption. I suspect we have things coming that will open a few more eyes, both on this topic and with respect to many of the things Paul has been preaching.
    De-legitimization is a thing.
    What hasn’t happened yet to the media is a build phase that produces something better,and really completes the push. The current alternative, which is metastisizing into a gateway-keeper to the regular media itself, is Facebook & Twitter. Both of whom have the same mental OS as the Chinese government, and behave in similar ways.
    Which gives us more than one problem to think about, and work on. Let everyone find the place they want to be.
    Meanwhile, de-construction is often as valuable to an ecosystem as construction. If the means seem lowly, well, such is nature. Ask the forest rangers near me why they start fires; it’s because the new sequoia trees won’t survive if they don’t. And I’m not thrilled with all the termites here, but I don’t think I’d like my surroundings at all if they didn’t exist. David Hurst makes this point in an excellent book on organizations:
    So… munch away, little dudes. Munch away. And if someone has to bring a bit of jellied gasoline now and again? Hey, light it up. It’ll give us the space we need to grow something.

Comments are closed.